As the new Greendale Subway shop opens in the cafeteria, Shirley, Pierce and Britta plot to bring about its early demise. Vice Dean Laybourne makes another attempt to get Troy…

Jeff falls into old habits after reconnecting with Alan (Rob Corddry), a former law firm colleague; Abed, Annie and Troy look for dirt on Alan.

Jeff and Britta meddle in Annie’s love life when she starts dating Britta’s ex, Vaughn. Meanwhile, Pierce feels left out of Troy and Abed’s movie night.